W.S. Gilbert never really wrote Nonsense; his Bab Ballads and other collections, while obviously influenced by Edward Lear ― especially in the strongly caricatural style of the pictures accompanying his poems in the early editions – are rather in the humorous narrative tradition of William Cowper’s “Diverting History of John Gilpin” and Thomas Hood’s “Miss Kilmansegg and Her Precious Leg.”

Early in his career, however, he produced imitations of Nonsense, the most famous ― owing to its publication history ― being perhaps “The Advent of Spring.” It first appeared anonymously in Fun in 1862:

THE ADVENT OF SPRING.

By a Devout Admirer of Mr. T―――――n.

Under the beechful eye,
When causeless brandlings bring,
Let the froddering crooner cry,
And the braddled sapster sing.
For never and never again
Will the tottering bauble bray,
For bratticed wrackers are singing aloud,
And the throngers croon in May!

The wracking globe unstrung,
Unstrung in the frittering light
Of a moon that knows no day!
Of a day that knows no night!
Diving away in the crowd
Of sparkling frets of spray,
The bratticed wrackers are singing aloud,
And the throngers croon in May!

Hasten, O hapful blue,
Blue of the thimmering brow,
Hasten to meet your crew,
They’ll clamour to pelt thee now!
For never again shall a cloud
Out-thribble the babbling day,
When bratticed wrackers are singing aloud,
And the throngers croon in May!

[WS Gilbert.] “The Advent of Spring.” Fun 1 February 1862, vol.1, p. 200.

The poem was then reprinted, apparently by mistake and with some variants, in Punch on 23 April 1873:

Shirley Brooks, editor of Punch at the time, wrote in his diary:

Miss Emily Leith has helped me into a mull. She sent me some things of her own some time back, and with them some very good nonsense verses in MS., which I also took to be hers, but which she says she told me were copied. If she did, I overlooked the statement, and having touched them up, used them this week, as they fitted a cut of Sambourne’s. Such things will happen, but I don’t do them often, usually eschewing outsiders.

And a few days later:

I inserted some verse sent me by Emily Leith, overlooking her distinct statement that she had copied them. So down come letters from Gilbert, who wrote them in Fun 10 years ago, Tom Hood and Burnand. Made the amende and wrote Gilbert. Mea culoa, and nobody else’s. (George Somes Layard, A Great Punch Editor. London: Sir Isaac Pitman & Sons, 1907. 542.)

“The Advent of Spring” is a parody of Tennyson’s notorious haziness of meaning, with particular reference perhaps to the poet laureate’s “The Progress of Spring” or “Early Spring.” The poem, with its profusion of invented words, sounds a lot like Lewis Carroll’s “Jabberwocky,” which would only appear ten years after the first Fun publication.

Tennyson is also mentioned in a second experiment with nonsense, which was published in Fun in two installments in 1865:

SOMETHING LIKE NONSENSE VERSES

1.―The Highland Jew.

I saw a red-haired Jew from Aberdeen,
In a gabardine,
At the Tabard Inn,
He wore a sword which was its scabbard in,
On a Wednesday!

2. ―The Pious Q.C.
   I saw Mr. Big Ben Denison,
   Ask a benison
   On some venison,
   Which he bought of Alfred Tennyson,
   On a Wednesday.
3. ―The Greek Maiden.
   I beg to state I love a yaller miss,
   Born at Salamis,
   And this gal, or miss,
   Bound to meet me down at Balham is,
   Every Wenesday!
4. ― The Worthy Independent Minister.
   A worthy Independent minister,
   Born at Finisterre,
   Turning sinister,
   Smothered his wife with fumes of kinaster
   On a Wednesday!
5. ―The Unhappy Marriage.
   Once I married a cook from charity,
   But disparity,
   And hair carroty,
   Made me treat her with barbarity
   Every Wednesday!
6. ―The Sensation Opera Troupe
   I know a man who’s going to offer Gye
   Anthropophagi
   (Or androphagi),
   Who will sing with French hippophagi
   Every Wednesday!

[WS Gilbert.] “Something Like Nonsense Verses.” Fun 10 June 1865, p. 31.

Something like Nonsense Verses.

No. II.

7. ―The Unfortunate Revellers.
   Tipsy gents, the type of snobbery,
   Drunk and slobbery,
   Make a bobbery,
   And the victims are of robbery

Every Wednesday.

8. ―The Jealous Dancer.
   As I Waltzed with Jane deliciously,
   Jones officiously,
   Injudiciously,
   Bumped against us both most viciously,
   On a Wednesday.
9. ―The Polite Student.
   A civil student at my college (he
   Learns horology
   And conchology)
   Offers me a full apology
   Every Wednesday.
10. ―The Undignified Nobleman.
    I know a nobleman whose publicity
    And complicity
    In mendacity
    Is a fact of authenticity
    Every Wednesday.
11. ―The Absurd Chancellor.
    Once a chancellor of acidity
    And timidity,
    With rapidity
    Used to sing “Run ti iddy ti!”
    Every Wednesday.

[WS Gilbert.] “Something like Nonsense Verses. No. II.” Fun 24 June 1865, p. 51.

The model for these short monorhyme five liners seems might have been Edward Lear’s A Book of Nonsense, whose third edition, the first one to be widely distributed, had been published to great acclaim in 1861.

For more on Gilbert’s little-known poems see: Ellis, James. “The Unsung W.S. Gilbert.” Harvard Library Bulletin 18.2 (1970): 109-40.