The lord of misrule
By Nicola Shulman
The British response to Dr Seuss has not, so far, been suitable reading for Ms Dimond-Cates. It may be that we have an embarrassment of excellent children’s writers of our own, whom we may take seriously instead, if we are so inclined; or it may be another aspect of our defensive hostility to a younger, ascendant culture. At any rate, the reviewer for Junior Bookshelf in 1963 thought Dr Seuss ‘often tiresome and sometimes vulgar… Compared with Edward Lear and Lewis Carroll he seems madly common, slick, unmemorable.’
[…]
Critics prospecting for artistic antecedents have, naturally, cited the impossible perspectives of Escher and the melting hardware of the surrealist movement. It is certainly true that the nearest things in creation to Dr Seuss’s krazy-golf Whoville are the concrete sculptures put up in the Mexican jungle by the Englishman Edward James, much under the influence of surrealism himself. But if I had to ascribe Seuss’s work to a school – pseud’s corner notwithstanding – I should choose one from literature, not painting: nonsense. Seuss may be the first nonsense painter.
Telegraph | 18 March 2004
Search this site:
Edward Lear
On Lear and Nonsense
- A Very Good Children’s Book (1865)
- Nonsense Verse, &c. (1880)
- Word-Twisting Versus Nonsense (1887)
- Concerning Nonsense (1889)
- Delightful Nonsense (1890)
- G.K. Chesterton, A Defence of Nonsense (1902)
- The Poems in Alice in Wonderland (1903)
- Limericks (1903)
- Ian Malcolm on Edward Lear (1908)
- G.K. Chesterton, Two Kinds of Paradox (1911)
- H. Jackson, Masters of Nonsense (1912)
- H. Hawthorne, Edward Lear (1916)
- G.K. Chesterton, Child Psychology and Nonsense (1921)
- How Pleasant to Know Mr Lear (1932)
- G.K. Chesterton, Both Sides of the Looking-Glass (1933)
- G.K. Chesterton, Humour (1938)
- G. Orwell, Nonsense Poetry (1945)
- George Orwell, Funny, But Not Vulgar (1945)
- Michele Sala, Lear’s Nonsense: Beyond Children’s Literature
- More Articles
Twitter Updates
- A Parallelebiped nonsenselit.com/2019/02/15/a-p… https://t.co/H9qHqBHA4U 2 days ago
- Countess Waldegrave and Baron Carlingford, part 2: The Breakfast Club and 'the Irish Question' - Untold lives blog blogs.bl.uk/untoldlives/20… 4 days ago
- Countess Waldegrave and Baron Carlingford, part 1: political influence and family ties - Untold lives blog blogs.bl.uk/untoldlives/20… 4 days ago
Categories
- Comics (63)
- Cruikshank (4)
- Dr. Seuss (22)
- Edward Gorey (13)
- Edward Lear (754)
- General (133)
- Gustave Verbeek (27)
- James Thurber (2)
- Lewis Carroll (64)
- Limerick (50)
- Nonsense Lyrics (19)
- Peter Newell (80)
- Podcasts (40)
- Punch (1)
- Uncategorized (14)
- WS Gilbert (1)